Contact Us Home
Press Release

PRESS CONFERENCE
TREATY RIGHTS LAWSUIT TO STOP RED HILL VALLEY EXPRESSWAY

HAMILTON, ON, November 27, 2003: Lawyers representing a Six Nations man and his descendants are commencing legal action against the City of Hamilton concerning the proposed Red Hill Valley Expressway. The expressway will violate and destroy Iroquois rights pursuant to a major Treaty between the then Five Iroquois Nations and the British Crown of 1701, or the “Nanfan Treaty”. Mr. Green will be seeking an injunction preventing the construction of the proposed expressway.

Lawyers Murray Klippenstein of Toronto and Andrew Orkin of Hamilton are representing Larry Green, one of the Iroquois Firepeople who lit the Ancestors' Sacred Fire in the Red Hill Valley in early August 2003. The fire was recently extinguished at the behest of the City of Hamilton by the Hamilton police.

“In 1701, it was solemnly agreed between the Crown and the Iroquois Nations that our people and our descendants would have hunting and land use rights and freedoms to the part of our country that includes the Red Hill Valley, ‘for ever’ and ‘free of all disturbances’. The planned expressway would destroy those rights. I intend my heirs and descendants to be able exercise these treaty rights and freedoms on this corner of undisturbed land, for ever.”

“Mr. Green has instructed us that that only an injunction to stop the expressway can protect his and his descendants’ perpetual treaty rights and freedoms in the Red Hill Valley, and that there is no amount of money which would be a reasonable or comparable replacement for these rights,” said Murray Klippenstein. “We are determined to obtain the injunction and prevent that destruction. But if for some unknown reason the courts decline to stop the expressway in the valley, the City should not assume or hope that this case will disappear. The 1701 treaty rights have extraordinary value in perpetuity, and they cannot legally be paved over with impunity. Accordingly, Mr Green is also claiming one hundred million dollars in compensation, to be set aside in a trust fund for traditional and cultural activities for his descendants.”

“The rights and freedoms arising out of treaties between the Crown and aboriginal peoples in Canada have been declared by the Supreme Court of Canada to be part of the highest law of the land,” said Andrew Orkin. “Mr Green is asking no more and no less than that the solemn promises made to his people by the Crown, and the very recent court and Crown affirmations of those promises, be honoured and upheld according to their very plain meaning. As repeated by the courts of Canada on numerous occasions, ‘The honour of the Crown is at stake.’

Further information:
Murray Klippenstein 416-598-0288
Andrew Orkin 905-522-7929


© Friends of Red Hill Valley 1991-2005

Sign our Petition!